CO129-342 - Governor Lugard & Public Offices - 1907 [11-12] — Page 54

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Hon. Colonial Secretary,

This Railway is being constructed under the "Departmental System". What that system is and how it is to be worked were defined and laid down in the important Memorandum which formed an enclosure to a despatch written by Mr. Lyttelton on 5th December, 1904, published in Blue Book Cd.2325. (Have you and the Chief Resident Engineer and the Local Auditor copies of this?) It is there said:- "By the Departmental system is meant that the Government becomes its own Contractor......the careful preparation of preliminaries affords the Government not only a reliable forecast of expenditure but also a means of watching and checking the progress of work. The success of the system depends almost entirely on the Government being able to entrust the control of the work to an officer of its own..............and on its being prepared to vest in that officer the same large measure of discretion as is given by a Contractor to his Chief Agent - usually styled the Chief Resident Engineer - He is engaged by the Government; he engages his own labour, orders through the Crown Agents his own materials. He is for discipline and general purposes the servant of the Government to whom he looks for instructions apart from the technical conduct of the works.

2.

I have omitted passages and only quoted what I wish to refer to. The Departmental system has been abused but I think that many of the criticisms directed against it are justified only by the fact that the Government has not realised its proper position and has in fact accepted the Chief Resident Engineer as though he were a Contractor. My view is (a) that he is "a servant of the Government" - "an Officer of its own" - responsible only for the technical work, and all instructions outside technical Railway construction emanate from the Government. It lies with the Government to grant him such a measure of discretion as it sees fit.

5.

I am personally of opinion that a Government should in its own interests closely supervise local Contracts, for

Edit History

2026-06-05 15:48:00 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Hon. Colonial Secretary, This Railway is being constructed under the "Departmental System". What that system is and how it is to be worked were defined and laid down in the important Memorandum which formed an enclosure to a despatch written by Mr. Lyttelton on 5th December, 1904, published in Blue Book Cd.2325. (Have you and the Chief Resident Engineer and the Local Auditor copies of this?) It is there said:- "By the Departmental system is meant that the Government becomes its own Contractor......the careful preparation of preliminaries affords the Government not only a reliable forecast of expenditure but also a means of watching and checking the progress of work. The success of the system depends almost entirely on the Government being able to entrust the control of the work to an officer of its own..............and on its being prepared to vest in that officer the same large measure of discretion as is given by a Contractor to his Chief Agent - usually styled the Chief Resident Engineer - He is engaged by the Government; he engages his own labour, orders through the Crown Agents his own materials. He is for discipline and general purposes the servant of the Government to whom he looks for instructions apart from the technical conduct of the works. 2. I have omitted passages and only quoted what I wish to refer to. The Departmental system has been abused but I think that many of the criticisms directed against it are justified only by the fact that the Government has not realised its proper position and has in fact accepted the Chief Resident Engineer as though he were a Contractor. My view is (a) that he is "a servant of the Government" - "an Officer of its own" - responsible only for the technical work, and all instructions outside technical Railway construction emanate from the Government. It lies with the Government to grant him such a measure of discretion as it sees fit. 5. I am personally of opinion that a Government should in its own interests closely supervise local Contracts, for
Baseline (Original)
53 Kill enrabrooos ni ngteeb add to moltusers bna moltqsonos aris #e7squiq;#NG/INTAVOD Isinofel eɗt to enottnetni art beteriba eta verið tærið offlanoqaer al bra jaoɔ to notamijas bits vmonode sub diźw betelɖmo ai Inow edź Jadið bræ,07 .noitibeque . ent dilw boðnuijns al teeniqni Smeble=f of: .(b) anot?oiitaal edt nahau atoa bas ftow ed to moltusexs Iasof To vidosTib raddle beyərnos „Jasantevoð Kalneled ant to qni bluenon eit dqvondt (aenas Ianolèqsxxe tud IIa ni) **TOONİYAE Izinolo0 est tot adno”λ ¿ažnega пworɔ OLT zaonkard Lainganlt bas Latsremmoo sit ab 1 -ÖNNST¬8 Tisabeɔen ede exam erit flow edt drtw betɔammOS zistretam bra metoda sandoruq,neltromme nii tol stanm -¿Ivano) erit neewded ●onebnoɖesTzoo Joubnos bra nem #gagne Isinole To sjadɛ to vzadatoer ødt bas roanigos gak- INAMOTOD #tosgå aworo eďd to soitto ‚#sinoi») add rot (*#9b480 [Lade#IrW .7.8 ,robnej .300[‚TIBUSIɗET Hon. Celonial Secretary, This Railway is being constructed under the "Departmental System". What that system is and how it is to be worked were defined and laid down in the important Memorandum which formed an enclosure to a despatch written by Mr. Lyttel- -ton on 5th. December, 1904, published in Blue Book Cd.2325. (Have you and the Chief Resident Engineer and the Local Auditor copies of this ?) It is there said:- "By the Departmental system is meant that the Government becomes its own Contracter ......the careful preparation of preliminaries affords the Government net only a reliable forecast of expenditure but also a means of watching and checking the progress of work. The success of the system depends almost entirely on the Government being able to entrust the control of the work to an officer of its own..............and on its being prepared to vest in that officer. the same large measure of discretien as is given by a Contractor te his Chief Agent -, usually styled the Chief Resident Engineer - He is engaged by the Government; he engages his own labour, orders through the Crown Agents his own materials. He is for discipline and general purposes the servant of the Government to whom he looks for instructions apart from the technical conduct of the works. 2. I have omitted passages and only quoted what I wish to refer te. The Departmental system has been abused but I think that many of the criticisms directed against it are justified only by the fact that the Government has not realised its proper position and has in fact accepted the Chief wh Resident Engineer as though he were a Contracter. My view is (a) that he is "a servant of the Government" - "an Officer of its *wn* - responsible only for the technical work, and all instructions outside technical Railway construction emanate from the Government, It lies with the Severnment te grant him such a measure of discretion as it sees fit. 5. I am personally of opinion that a Government should in its own interests closely supervise local Contracts, for
2026-06-05 15:48:00 · Baseline
View content

53

Kill enrabrooos ni ngteeb add to moltusers bna moltqsonos

aris #e7squiq;#NG/INTAVOD Isinofel eɗt to enottnetni art

beteriba eta verið tærið offlanoqaer al bra jaoɔ to notamijas

bits vmonode sub diźw betelɖmo ai Inow edź Jadið bræ,07

.noitibeque

.

ent dilw boðnuijns al teeniqni Smeble=f of: .(b)

anot?oiitaal edt nahau atoa bas ftow ed to moltusexs Iasof

To vidosTib raddle beyərnos „Jasantevoð Kalneled ant to

qni bluenon eit dqvondt (aenas Ianolèqsxxe tud IIa ni)

**TOONİYAE

Izinolo0 est tot adno”λ në ¿ažnega пworɔ OLT

zaonkard Lainganlt bas Latsremmoo sit ab 1

-ÖNNST¬8 Tisabeɔen ede exam erit flow edt drtw betɔammOS

zistretam bra metoda sandoruq,neltromme nii tol stanm

-¿Ivano) erit neewded ●onebnoɖesTzoo Joubnos bra nem #gagne

Isinole To sjadɛ to vzadatoer ødt bas roanigos gak-

INAMOTOD

#tosgå aworo eďd to soitto ‚#sinoi») add rot (*#9b480 [Lade#IrW

.7.8 ,robnej

.300[‚TIBUSIɗET

Hon. Celonial Secretary,

This Railway is being constructed under the

"Departmental System". What that system is and how it is to be

worked were defined and laid down in the important Memorandum

which formed an enclosure to a despatch written by Mr. Lyttel-

-ton on 5th. December, 1904, published in Blue Book Cd.2325.

(Have you and the Chief Resident Engineer and the Local Auditor copies of this ?) It is there said:- "By the Departmental

system is meant that the Government becomes its own Contracter

......the careful preparation of preliminaries affords the

Government net only a reliable forecast of expenditure but also a means of watching and checking the progress of work. The

success of the system depends almost entirely on the Government

being able to entrust the control of the work to an officer of

its own..............and on its being prepared to vest in that officer.

the same large measure of discretien as is given by a Contractor

te his Chief Agent -, usually styled the Chief Resident Engineer

- He is engaged by the Government; he engages his own labour,

orders through the Crown Agents his own materials. He is for

discipline and general purposes the servant of the Government

to whom he looks for instructions apart from the technical

conduct of the works.

2.

I have omitted passages and only quoted

what I wish to refer te. The Departmental system has been

abused but I think that many of the criticisms directed against

it are justified only by the fact that the Government has not

realised its proper position and has in fact accepted the Chief

wh

Resident Engineer as though he were a Contracter. My view is

(a) that he is "a servant of the Government" - "an Officer of its

*wn* - responsible only for the technical work, and all

instructions outside technical Railway construction emanate

from the Government, It lies with the Severnment te grant him

such a measure of discretion as it sees fit.

5.

I am personally of opinion that a Government

should in its own interests closely supervise local Contracts,

for

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.